The Problem with giving clients WordPress Admin Access

WordPress Admin Access: The Challenges of Granting Clients Admin Access in WordPress vs. the Controlled Freedom of Headless CMS Solutions like Storyblok

When developing custom WordPress websites, one of the most contentious points between developers and clients often revolves around administrative access to their WordPress website. Many clients expect to receive “admin” access to their website, believing this equates to ownership and control. However, granting this level of access introduces a range of challenges that can negatively impact the security, functionality, and perceived value of a custom solution. By comparing WordPress workflows to headless CMS options like Storyblok, we can explore how different content management approaches impact developers and clients.

The Problem with Giving Clients WordPress Admin Access

WordPress’s administrator account role is designed to provide unrestricted access to virtually all areas of the website, from plugins and themes to users and settings. While this might seem empowering for clients, it often causes more harm than good. Here’s why:

1. Encourages a "DIY Culture"

Clients with admin access are often tempted to experiment with plugins, themes, and settings, believing they can manage plugins and make significant improvements without consulting the developer. This DIY culture can lead to:

Overloading with plugins: Clients may install unnecessary or incompatible plugins, which can lead to slower performance or outright site crashes.

Unintentional breaking changes: Adjusting settings, deactivating critical plugins, or altering theme files can result in irreversible damage to the site.

Inviting others with admin access: Clients may grant admin rights to unqualified team members, creating confusion and compounding errors.

2. Security Vulnerabilities

Admin access opens the door to a range of security risks, such as:

Too many admin users: Each additional admin, especially when creating a new user, increases the attack surface for hackers. The entire site is at risk if one admin account has a weak password.

Malware via third-party plugins: Unscrupulous plugin downloads can introduce vulnerabilities, compromising the website and server environment.

3. Devaluation of the Developer's Role

Clients with full admin access may view their custom WordPress site as a commodity akin to off-the-shelf platforms like Webflow or Wix, often misusing the WordPress dashboard. This perception leads to several issues:

Firing and hiring developers freely: The client may switch developers without understanding the complexities of their custom solution, which can make long-term site management chaotic.

Undermining the custom solution’s value: Clients might treat it as a generic tool rather than a tailored solution that demands care without recognizing the expertise that went into their site.

Understanding the Challenges of WordPress Admin Access

Managing a WordPress site often involves navigating a complex landscape of user roles and permissions. While the WordPress admin role offers extensive control over the site, it also introduces several challenges that can impact security, functionality, and overall site management. Understanding these challenges is crucial for maintaining a secure and efficient WordPress site.

1. Security Risks of Granting Admin Access

Granting admin access to multiple users can significantly increase the security risks associated with your WordPress site. With admin privileges, users have complete control over the site, including the ability to install plugins, change themes, and modify core files. This level of access can lead to unintended changes, security vulnerabilities, and even data breaches. To mitigate these risks, it’s essential to limit admin access to only those who absolutely need it. Additionally, implementing strong passwords and two-factor authentication can further enhance security, ensuring that only authorized users can make critical changes.

2. Limited Control over User Roles and Permissions

WordPress comes with a predefined set of user roles and permissions, which can be limiting for larger organizations or sites with complex access requirements. The default roles—Administrator, Editor, Author, Contributor, and Subscriber—may not provide the granularity needed to manage access effectively. To overcome this limitation, plugins like User Role Editor or Members can be used to create custom user roles and permissions. These tools allow you to tailor access levels to fit the specific needs of your site, ensuring that users have the appropriate permissions without compromising security.

3. Difficulty in Scaling and Maintaining a WordPress Site

As your WordPress site grows, managing and maintaining it can become increasingly challenging. With multiple users, plugins, and themes, keeping track of changes, updates, and security patches can be daunting. This complexity can lead to performance issues, security vulnerabilities, and even downtime. To address these challenges, it’s crucial to use a robust hosting solution that can handle increased traffic and data. Additionally, optimizing your site for performance and using security plugins like Jetpack or Wordfence can help maintain site integrity and security. Regular maintenance and updates are essential to ensure your site runs smoothly and securely.

What is a Headless CMS?

A headless CMS represents a modern approach to content management, separating the backend content management functionality from the frontend presentation layer. This decoupling allows for greater flexibility and scalability, making it an attractive option for developers and content editors alike.

1. What is a Headless CMS used for?

A headless CMS is a backend-only content management system that manages content and delivers it to the frontend through APIs. This architecture allows developers to use any frontend framework or library to build the user interface, while the CMS handles content management and storage. Headless CMS platforms like Storyblok, Contentful, and Strapi offer a flexible and scalable solution for managing content across multiple channels and devices.

By leveraging a headless CMS, developers can focus on creating a custom user interface without being constrained by the limitations of a traditional CMS. Content editors, on the other hand, can manage and publish content independently, without worrying about breaking the site’s functionality. This separation of concerns enables complete control over both the frontend and backend, leading to faster development cycles, improved performance, and enhanced security. Additionally, headless CMS platforms often come with advanced features like content modeling, workflow management, and collaboration tools, making it easier to manage complex content workflows and ensure consistency across different platforms and devices.

How Client Admin Access Complicates Regular WordPress Maintenance

Granting clients admin roles in WordPress introduces significant challenges when it comes to maintaining the website. Regular maintenance is a critical part of ensuring the longevity, security, and performance of a website, and it typically includes tasks like updating plugins, fixing bugs, and addressing security vulnerabilities. When clients have unrestricted admin access, this maintenance process becomes far more difficult for developers. Here’s why:

1. Uncontrolled Plugin Updates and Additions: Manage Plugins and Themes

Clients with admin privileges may update plugins on their own, often without checking for compatibility with the website’s theme or other plugins. This can lead to:

Site-breaking updates: A single incompatible plugin update can cause critical functionality to fail.

Redundant plugins: Clients may install plugins without understanding their purpose, resulting in conflicts or performance issues.

When developers, especially frontend developers, are called in to address these problems, they often spend more time unraveling the changes than performing regular updates.

2. Changes to Site Settings

Clients with admin access may inadvertently modify core site settings that developers rely on for stability. These changes might include:

• Adjusting permalinks can break SEO and internal links.
• Disabling important features or tools critical for performance or security.
• Activating unnecessary features that impact site speed or functionality.

Undoing these changes adds to the maintenance workload and costs more time and resources.

3. Increased Security Vulnerabilities

With admin privileges, clients may:

• Invite untrained team members as additional admins, which enables users to make risky changes, increasing the risk of accidental errors or breaches.
• Use weak passwords, leaving the site vulnerable to hacking attempts.
• Install plugins from untrusted sources that may contain malware or vulnerabilities.

These issues require immediate attention and can damage the site’s reputation or lead to data loss, further complicating a developer’s maintenance efforts.

4. Lack of Clear Ownership for Maintenance Tasks

When clients have full admin access, the boundaries between their responsibilities and the developer’s role often blur. This can lead to:

• Confusion about who is responsible for addressing issues.
• Duplicate efforts, where both parties attempt fixes, potentially causing further conflicts.
• Delays in resolving problems due to miscommunication.

5. Undermining Preventive Maintenance

Preventive maintenance, such as monitoring for outdated plugins or applying minor security updates, is rendered ineffective if clients constantly make changes. Developers may struggle to implement a consistent maintenance schedule if they repeatedly clean up after client modifications.

Solutions

To ensure smooth and effective maintenance, it's essential to establish boundaries and create a workflow that minimizes interference. Some possible solutions include:

Custom Roles: Assign clients roles with limited capabilities, such as content editing, while reserving admin access for developers.

Education: Provide clear documentation or training to help clients understand their role and the importance of leaving specific tasks to the developer.

Headless CMS: Platforms like Storyblok eliminate this issue by separating content management from development, ensuring that maintenance tasks remain under developer control.

By restricting admin access and fostering a collaborative approach, developers can maintain the site’s integrity while reducing the risk of unnecessary downtime or security breaches.

‍

How Headless CMS Platforms like Storyblok Solve These Challenges

Headless CMS platforms such as Storyblok take a completely different approach to content management. A headless CMS separates the backend content management from the frontend presentation layer, allowing for greater flexibility and scalability. By decoupling the content from the presentation layer, these platforms inherently avoid many pitfalls associated with WordPress’s admin structure.

1. No Developer-Level Access for Clients

In a headless CMS, clients are limited to managing their content and assets through a well-defined interface. They do not have access to code, server settings, or developer tools, which eliminates:

• Accidental changes that break functionality.
• Plugin overloads or compatibility issues.
• Security vulnerabilities tied to admin overreach.

Headless CMS platforms protect the site's integrity by restricting access to only what clients need while allowing clients to focus on content.

2. Granular Permissions for Content Management

Storyblok allows developers to assign specific roles and permissions that define what users can and cannot do. This ensures:

• Clients can edit their content without fear of affecting core functionality.
• Security risks are minimized by restricting access to sensitive areas.

3. Reinforces the Value of Developers

Since Storyblok’s workflow separates content management from development, clients inherently understand the value of their developer. They rely on developers for:

• Custom frontend implementations.
• Maintenance of integrations and APIs.
• Ongoing development of new features.

This structure fosters a professional relationship where developers are seen as indispensable partners rather than interchangeable service providers.

Granular Permissions in WordPress: A Partial Solution

In WordPress, plugins like Members or User Role Editor can create custom roles that grant clients specific capabilities without full admin access. For example, you can create a "Content Manager" role that allows clients to manage pages, posts, and media while locking down plugin installations and theme settings.

While this is a step in the right direction, it comes with challenges:

1. Clients Know the "Admin" Role Exists: Savvy clients may still request admin access, and explaining the limitations of custom roles can lead to friction.

2. Granular Permissions Are Complex: Fine-tuning permissions requires careful consideration, as too many restrictions can frustrate clients, while too few undermine the purpose.

Why Storyblok is the Superior Choice for Both Developers and Clients

Benefits for Developers

Freedom to focus on development: With no plugin conflicts or DIY experimentation, developers can build robust, scalable frontends.

Easier maintenance: A controlled environment minimizes the need for frequent troubleshooting caused by client interference.

Benefits for Clients

Intuitive content management: Storyblok’s user-friendly interface empowers clients to manage their content without fear of breaking the site.

Peace of mind: Clients can confidently make updates without worrying about security vulnerabilities or crashes.

Conclusion

Granting clients admin access in WordPress can spark a cascade of challenges, from security risks to site instability and a devaluation of the developer’s role. By contrast, headless CMS platforms like Storyblok offer a controlled, client-friendly solution that avoids these pitfalls. While WordPress can be customized to restrict client permissions, the very existence of the admin role often complicates matters.

For developers and clients alike, the Storyblok model creates a collaborative, professional relationship that values expertise and empowers clients without compromising security or functionality. This fundamental shift in how content management is approached benefits everyone involved, making it a clear winner for modern web projects.